Negima!? anime and manga

[FireHacker]

i just got done watching the anime and i was like...wow...this is bad ***....
and than i heard a rumor that the manga is alot better..

if u read and watched Negima plz put ur opinion about both...

[shinzou]

The manga is addictive and really good. Negima! (with one exclamation point or two at times) is the anime adaption of the manga, but the second half is made up because the manga hasn't yet reached it's end. The anime Negima!? (with exclamation and question mark) is a spin off series which I reakon was badly done. The Pactio concept was kind of remade and in my opinion "Ruined!".

So I'd think you should read the manga cause the anime versions are really bad incomparison.

[~*Starleaf*~]

The anime was good on my opinion. The characters were very different from one another and it brought me a lot of laughs.

I checked out the manga, yes.. WAY different than the anime. But I have yet to watch Negima?!.

[jtdlives]

I've read the magna and watched the anime. I thought the anime was ok, but I really like the magna. The magna and the anime have a little bit in common but the magna is more in depth about the charcters and the story line is much better.

[Konata Izumi]

I haven't actually watched the anime but I've seen screencaps and tiny bits of it, it doesn't seem to suit my taste so I'm sticking with the manga.