two sentence horror stories

[Clayton_n]

it's a thin line between safety an unspeakable danger. For those that don't know there is a show called Two Sentence Horror Stories which begins with one seemingly harmless sentence and hen after you watch the horror adds another to screw with your mind. personally i thought the first season was the best and the newer ones are a bit predictable in comparison.


So, how would you turn the first sentence into a nightmare with the second?

Examples:

I feel so safe snuggled up in my bed.
[spoiler]If only i was allowed to leave.

or

Until I realize I'm not alone. [spoiler]

That puppy was so cute.

 

Even with the finger sticking out of his mouth.

i saw a missing person's poster today.

 

It had my face on it.

[CapnJack]

I took a nice hot relaxing bath last night...


...St. Peter said the portable stereo was a bad investment.


-------------
My wife makes the funniest faces when I poke her...


...She just stopped making them after about 30 of them in a row.


-------------
My neighbor's dog has a wonderful liter of 5 puppies...


... If mine wasn't so hungry it would have been 7.


-------------
The convenient store clerk needed to see my ID...


... I showed him my wanted poster.








...like that?

[Clayton_n]

Nice! But no ... just . And spoiler the second one.

I opened a new book today.
This Alhazred guy should write a sequel.