Originally Posted by
Matas
No, im not going to respect those who made it. The writing in it is bad enough that it seems like they're treating the viewers like idiots.
I was stating my reasoning for thinking it's bad and hating it, I don't understand why people would blindly love something and ignore it's faults. I see Madoka Magica get trashed all the time, but I still recognize it's faults and like it. If you think points someone made about something are wrong then dispute them, that's what I like to do and that shouldn't be a problem on an anime forum. If you think they are right about a bunch of negative points on a show you like, then recognize it's faults and move on, I never went as far as to insult it's fans.
I shouldn't have to say that something is just my opinion because that is obvious, i'm just critically evaluating it a bit more than most people seemingly do. It's better to explain it's faults when saying something is terrible rather than just saying "it's awful" or something.
I was being friendly in the sense that I was lenient with it and didn't even point out 1/5th of the flaws I saw in it.
Bookmarks