Fairy Tail or One Piece?

[ScarletTail98]

I love both Fairy Tail and One Piece a lot...but One Piece is obviously better. It has a more intruiging plot and well placed comedy and action. I kinda dislike how the fights end in fairy tail. Especially Natsu vs Laxus and Rogue & Sting vs. Jiemma. They only used friendship power and it didn't make sense. But in One Piece, Luffy struggled a lot against the opponents showing more character development. And Doflamingo vs. Luffy was just amazing! *-*

[Stunning3]

Fairy Tail is very very repetitive. One Piece is just amazing with a vast plot. One Piece>>>>>Fairy Tail.

[SaraG25]

I've only watched a little bit of One Piece and I did enjoy that, but I like Fairy Tail a bit more.

[Ibukii]

Personally, I've seen both of them before, but I've seen more of One Piece and I LOVE it. When I watched Fairy Tail, I watched around 30 episodes and eventually just got too bored to try and watch it anymore.

[Metak37]

I vote for one piece, only because the enemies in one piece are interesting, and they have backstories and they may show up again, compared to fairy tail, where they just kinda introduce you to a random dark guild with a bunch of names you will never memorize and at least one cute girl with big boobs. And then they disappear after the arc. -_-

[Astral_Mage]

One Piece for sure, better plot, & better character development, I watched few episodes of Fairy Tail before dropping the show, not because it was bad, it actually attracted me to watch more of it, but I couldn't make time for it considering the other choices I had.
I like Fairy Tail, but I like One Piece a whole lot more.

[立华奏]

l\(^o^)/YES!

[Ayume Tayu-chan]

they are very different to compare between.
One piece is more mature,like fairy tail senpai...and its plot, ideas, characters are nothing like each other. they are both practical to the friendship thing but it end there.
In fairy tail natsu need to save the heroine every second and he will always stay last to stand and win the fight with "friendship power".
In one piece they are a group, yes luffy will fight the strongest, but everyone will contribute and win against their enemy with power they trained to achieve. Each arc will be at a different country, not "the heroine got kidnapped again" or something like this. They try to solve the issue of the country and on the way get along and earn friends.

I don't mean to say Fairy Tail is bad- I liked it in the beginning, till it became repetitive. I just honestly believe they are not meant to be compared as they are not very similar. But by my preference I do like One Piece a lot more. Hope I didn't offend Fairy Tail fans( I do know it gets better in the current chapters of the manga, my opinion is only on the first 5-6 arcs of the anime ) .

[someoneofforumpast]

They both serve their purpose in my life.

[Peppermint Hearts]

I like Fairy Tale much better, it's more of a fantasy with magic. One Piece never did appeal to me, and has way too many episodes to catch up on the series anyway.

[Meruem]

One Piece

[Holocast]

I prefer Fairy Tale, because I like the theme and story line a bit better and I really love the characters.