View Full Version : [Annual Contest] Sig Master 2007 Voting

09-18-2007, 08:19 AM
Hey all,
here is what everyone were waiting for ... the voting.
We've got 26 entries and here they are to compete to access the semifinals. We will take 14 sigs with most votes and let them continue the path that leads them to the top. But before doing that we need your votes.

The voting will have the following rules::
- you can vote for max 3 works of art. You can choose less than 3, but not more or I will ignore your post completely;
- you can vote only once. Keep in mind we can find out if you have voted more than once with different accounts;
- you cannot vote for yourself;
- try to explain why you voted for that sig (I would appreciate that :p);
- the contest is anonymous, so please, if you recognize somebody keep that information for yourself.

The voting will end on Saturday (9/22/2007)!

Let's play a fair game, OK. ;)

Here come the sigs:
Entry no.1 - angelic_assasin:

Entry no.2 - baka_black:

Entry no.3 - Hitsugaya389:

Entry no.4 - Shodaime:

Entry no.5 - jechocochan:

Entry no.6 - Zantetsuken:

Entry no.7 - Eikichi Onizuka:

Entry no.8 - hatoko_hinata:

09-18-2007, 08:20 AM
Entry no.9 - Sonata:

Entry no.10 - Konata Izumi:

Entry no.11 - shougo amakousa:

Entry no.12 - Wonderwice:

Entry no.13 - Draconocturn:

Entry no.14 - cool_tria_anime:

Entry no.15 - buhbibutterfly:

Entry no.16 - MaruDashi:

Entry no.17 - Jagan Eye:

Entry no.18 - Mira Kaiba:

09-18-2007, 08:20 AM
Entry no.19 - Myrra:

Entry no.20 - Gandizzl:

Entry no.21 - Gintara:

Entry no.22 - -Ookami-:

Entry no.23 - Hawkatex:

Entry no.24 - Nespa:

Entry no.25 - X-Wind:

Entry no.26 - ~World of Elegance~:

09-18-2007, 08:52 AM
My votes go to entries:

10 [its simple, cute, and I like the very subtle details in it]

12 [I like the bg, though I wish so much of it didnt overlay on the character]

21 [Its simple, yet the detailing is eye catching. I like how it looks like hes breaking through the sig]

09-18-2007, 09:08 AM
entry 10 - awesome, blending is perfect. Very cute also.
entry 15 - background matches image. Love the background.
entry 20 - Great blending. Color-use stands out.

09-18-2007, 11:03 AM
Whoa... There are many good entries this year. Hard to choose which three are the best. After pain stakingly examine each entries, here are my choices:

No. 15 ~ Clean and yet still able to blend into the background.
No. 16 ~ Simplicity that really reflect the chibi-ness of the design.
No. 25 ~ Chibi and yet able to retain the chibi-ness and well balanced between the stock and the BG.

'nough said...

09-18-2007, 11:09 AM
Wowz so hard to choose.
2. Love the background. Really eye-catching
15. Very creative. Gaara. Bamboos. XD sweeet
21. Same as Marudashi~ Like the way he's breaking through the sig. Oh and the background is nice too.
Good luck to all of you who entered the contest!

09-18-2007, 11:45 AM
Entry 10: Simple but it really works.

Entry 12: I like the startling contrast of a cute chibi with the grunge like bg.

Entry 16: It's like simplicity defined. Very cute.^^

Well, that's my vote. Good luck to everybody.^^

09-18-2007, 12:26 PM
My choices have fallen on the following signatures:

no. 15. The character is eyecatching, it looks completely adorable and it's cool how the panda theme is carried through the whole sig, with the bamboo and all. Very nice...
no. 18. The background really fits the character in a few ways. One the color, two the expression fits the way the background is made. It all fits and last but not least it looks awesome.
no. 21. The background is just pure awesome, the detailing is great, even though the quality of the scan could have been improved some.

Good luck to all the contestants

boohoooo I couldn't finish my entry on time x3

~World of Elegance~
09-18-2007, 12:45 PM
Entry 15 - Lol, that is adorable...I especially like the background.
Entry 17 - I like the whole Bamboo and Panda theme too..I didn't even know that was Gaara..o.o;
Entry 25 - I really like how that one was done..it's cute.

09-18-2007, 12:53 PM
Great sings. My vote goes for:

#16: So simple and cute. The background attracted me the most. Whoever did it is a good graphic designer.

#20: Great character and background.

#21: Awesome background and... lol @Naruto. I also like the warm colours. Goes well with the image.

It was hard choosing only three. @_@; Good luck to everybody.

Jagan Eye
09-18-2007, 01:38 PM
I chose:
10: I love the way the background was done and incorporated into the whole thing.
15: I like the Gaara Bambooo!!!
25: They are really cute, the three of them! I love it.

09-18-2007, 02:13 PM
~ #10: Simple and cute.
~ #17: Looks sophisticated and it's nicely done.
~ #13: I like the way the character poses and I like the style.

09-18-2007, 04:34 PM
2.couse i love naruto
14.Love the look
17. Couse its koo

09-18-2007, 05:39 PM
Entry 1: Because I love CCS, and the sig itself is very colourful.

09-18-2007, 06:02 PM
#16: It's simple and thus it makes ChibiMaru so kawaii!

09-18-2007, 06:30 PM
1 - Feels light and airy and happy, so perfect for Sakura.

15 - Tt looks like the chibi is hiding in the jungle, so adorable yet creepy.

26 - All those lines, looks like it took a lot of effort and I think it suits the anime well.

And for all of them, the colors used work very well with the chibi.

Kawairashii hikari
09-18-2007, 06:39 PM
10. It's really nice, it seems to me like the contents of the image just go together nicely

15. I just love the color effects around the character, it's very adorable in his little panda suit!

22. I like the character, the background and 'teh big sword' ^_^

09-18-2007, 07:16 PM
18~awesome so CUTE
22~Really good I <3 it
17~I think it the best one so good

09-18-2007, 07:54 PM
17 - It looks nicely grunged.
26 - Probably the one that stands out the most. No one else did one like that.

09-18-2007, 08:06 PM
I'm going to vote..ohhhhh so many great entries to choose from.<3

Entry 12 ~ I love the way the background was done and the chibi was very cute.=3
Entry 15 ~ Luv they way the background matches Gaara as a panda.
Entry 22 ~ Cause she has a big sword.<3 (it was very eye-catching and interesting.I like the background and the chibi.So kawaii.)

Good luck everyone who entered!

Mira Kaiba
09-18-2007, 08:28 PM
Yay - so many great entries to choose from!! XD

Entry 2: It's kawaii and clean, and simply nice.

Entry 16: Simple, stands out, clean and crisp, nice coloring.

Entry 25: I love the texture behind the main images, and again, is very clean. I like the way it is split into 3 sections as well. Plus its kawaii! XD

Good luck to everyone! <3

09-18-2007, 09:15 PM
Entry 1: How could I not pick it? Its the one that stood out to me the most, very cute and I love the colors (naturally)

Entry 16: Well I'm a sanrio fan, and I thought the colors used went well with the character. Its nice and clean-cut.

Entry 18: The picture is so cute, and again I like the colors and how it blends.

This was hard, good luck everyone, there's lots of nice ones. ^.^

09-19-2007, 12:30 AM
10 because those chicks are so cute :3
20 because he looks like cloud XD!
26 because it's just all around awesome with good composition (see I'm not a complete air head!)


09-19-2007, 12:45 AM
20 - Its the most unique in here XD
21 - love the splatter BG. and the render blends quite nicely
22 - Most adorable Winner.

Petrol Gas
09-19-2007, 04:26 AM
Mine would be
10. I love the arrangement between the background and the characters.
12. The background is the reason here, it's a good contrast.
16. I like the color layout on this one...

09-19-2007, 04:40 AM
22- I love the idea of a chibi lugging around 'teh big sword'. It's adorable too.

23- Unique and evil looking. The colours look nice.

25- Very cute. The background colours match.

09-19-2007, 04:55 AM
My votes would have to go to
15, 23 and 25 ^_^

Goodluck guys!

shougo amakousa
09-19-2007, 05:38 AM
18: perfectly chibi
2:It is just too adorable and I love the bg.
22:Very cute,creative and awesome text XD.

09-19-2007, 08:27 AM
Ehh..? My votes will go for...
#21..love the background. And it's.. Naruto. [Heh-heh.. kidding.]
#20...the effects..! it's cool.
#16...it's.. cute. >__<

09-19-2007, 09:03 AM
The ones that caught my eyes <.< xD

Entry#13 - Background looks good and it fits with the render/stock. + it's 13 xD

Entry#21 - Awesome style! Text placement and etc.

Entry#22 - Nice render/stock/extraction/ w/e choice, Cool text/font selection and... the border lol

Edit: Is it just me or entry no.9 doesn't load?

09-19-2007, 11:52 AM
My votes are going to have to go to the following entries:

Entry 10: The background is awesome and it looks well put together overall, plus the Chibi looks so cute ...

Entry 17: I love this Sig, it looks amazing and it stands out from the other entries for me ^-^ Good Job!

and finally ... Entry 26: Again, Love this Sig and amazing, stands out again from the other entries.

Overall though, Good Luck to all the contestants and they all look amazing ^-^

09-19-2007, 02:44 PM
uhm well i only see entry 1-8. My vote would be for entry 1 its cute and flows.

09-19-2007, 04:43 PM
Wow this is hard so many good sigs and can only vote for 3...

ok here goes...

#10 - i love the extraction that was used. Also the colors are nice and they blend well. I love the background effects. Also the text is nice.

#11 - Chibi gaara is to adorable.. Love the blackground and the blue that was used. Nice effects also. Text isnt bad either.

#21 - Like the naruto extraction and the background to me is awesome. Also nice colors. It was made very well and is also my favorite.

Man that was hard so many great sigs everyone did a totally awesome job.

09-19-2007, 09:04 PM
Im going for

1 because Sakura is so KAWAII! in the sig!
9 because eveni would say that!
24 because i love Ouran High School Host Club!

09-19-2007, 09:28 PM
Rats. I didn't make the deadline. This is what I get for being inactive I guess x_x; Aw well. Great entries.

I'll vote for:

17- It's a bit more complex than my usual liking, but I enjoy it this time around. Looks like quite a bit of work.

20- It's a great chibi extraction xD And I like the warm lighting.

25- chibis are adorable xD It's clear, cut and simple. Everything I look for in a signature.

I'm not a fan of complexity, so I just voted for the ones that immediately caught my eye. Respect goes out to all the hard work AF.

09-19-2007, 10:08 PM
The Number 2, 22, and the 25 get my votes.

09-20-2007, 01:49 AM
7- sharp lines and consistant red, white, blue theme make it stand out.
13- the text and splochy(sp?) background work great together with Vash
26- I really like the tech/barcode theme being used on such a cute chibi of the major.

Not bad works at all. Shame only 3 could be picked, but its better then asking to rule out only 1 I guess.

I worked on one myself but missed the deadline due to my lateness and a painful injured wrist. No sympathy, Im just whining. ^^;

Konata Izumi
09-20-2007, 02:12 AM
#11 - Quite an amazing background and good light source.
#12 - Stunning colors that create a good effect near the light source.
#20 - The character looks like he's about to burst out of the siggy, which is a rather interesting effect.

Good Luck to Everyone. =]

09-20-2007, 03:28 PM
12, 22, 25 get my vote~

09-20-2007, 03:28 PM
T'was hard to choose this year :/
Anywho x3

I vote for :

#10: Cute, simple and I adore the colouring.

#12 : It's freakin' souseiseki *__* and adorable x3

#15: I love the way Chibi Gaara is incorperated into the background
and how he matches and blends well with the jungle-scene.

The Majority were awesome, took me some time to choose x3
Good Luck <3 ~

09-20-2007, 07:47 PM
1 - I vote for this one because I really love the colors, and the colors and shapes made Sakura look adorable. :D

16 - I love the simplicity. 8DD

15 - Panda Gaara amuses me. :D

Honestly, I love all of them. n_n Sadly, I had to pick only three, so three I picked. O:

09-21-2007, 05:24 AM
12: The effects are quite nicely blended

15: The blending it nice and the sig is kawaii

21: It is simple yet attractive!

09-21-2007, 05:11 PM
entry 1-it stands out to me the most with bright colours. really pretty ^^

Beyond The Grave
09-21-2007, 07:37 PM
25, 21, and 15

These are the only ones that I can say that I will vote for. Doesn't mean I really like them but I applaud them for thier expression.

09-22-2007, 08:40 AM
WAh! I should've entered. They're all soo cute, but 3, huh? OK.
I voted for:

#16 - The background was so cute. The vector style stood out. The background was so simple, but nice.
#17 - I love Kadaj. The background was awesome. So much detail. And the 2 brothers were there too! haha.
#21 - The backgroung and style was unique. I loved the effects and colors.

09-22-2007, 09:32 AM
My votes goes to:

Entry no.9 - Because it's adorable and the background + stock really suits the word "Princess". Border looks original too.
Entry no.10 - I like how it looks "simple" but you can still tell that there's some effort behind it.
Entry no.22 - Kawaii and colorful! ^__^