Dobby or Gollum?

[Bulf]

Which do you like better? Dobby or Gollum/Smeagle?

Dobby all the way for me.

[Baka]

I went with Dobby as well.

[Kaitou Ace]

Well it almost has to be Dobby. Gollum is more pitiful, a barely sane creature sustained only by his wish to reclaim that which has twisted his soul. O_o;

[Ωmega]

Its all about Gurgi <33


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVL42dg2sd4

[AVAlution]

Dobby !

Harry Potter > anything.

[The Strategist]

Gollum would kick Dobby's ass lol

[Eris]

I'm not reallyinto poemon, but igess that pickashoe is good.

[Kaitou Ace]

I'm not reallyinto poemon, but igess that pickashoe is good.

http://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/not_really_into_pokemon.png

[Eris]

Thats the one.

[Lily Rock]

Gollum.
My father is scared of me cause I sound like him.

[Nesh]

Dobby of course!

[Chigumi]

Dobby all the way! However,
I can do the Gollum voice, lolz. Always cracks me and my friends up .. xD

[Elukien]

Gollum because he's one insane hobbit who isn't crazy about a teenage boy.

[Twelfth]

Dobby.

[animeyay]

I was also gonna answer with a Pokémon reference, since I seriously thought it said "smeargle" instead of "smeagol".

But Gollum I guess, just 'cause he looks meaner and more badassy.

[feifeifei]

Gollum would help me reclaim my precious. Sadly I'd probably have to kill him after, but all's fair.

[Uta-chan~]

Gollum >w<

[Aleyna]

Dobby, because he is good. ^_^

[Meenah]

I only know Dobby. Love that dude.

[Meteorkeeper]

Gollem, You got to admire his determination...and dobby kind of creeped me out for some reason.

[OtakuInu!!!]

I like Harry Potter more than TLOTR so I choose Dobby. Even though he died. T_T

[Uncanny X-Man]

I'm more of a Harry Potter fan, but still, I felt Gollum was a way better character than Dobby, of course there was (in my opinion) also more focus on Gollum in the LOTR books than there was on Dobby in the Harry Potter books, so yeah, Gollum all the way.

[YuriEcchiGirl]

Dobby from the Harry Potter movies all the way! ^^

[Manhattan_Project_2000]

Well it almost has to be Dobby. Gollum is more pitiful, a barely sane creature sustained only by his wish to reclaim that which has twisted his soul. O_o;

Strangely enough, that's the exact argument I was going to give for Pro-Gollum.

[-GAZKUL-]

Dobby= Cute

Gollum = Teeth curlingly annoying