Signature of the week #50 Voting

[Archaic Devices]

Ok, so there's been a change in the voting. You no longer have to post why you're voting for a certain entry because we are using a poll system now. But please keep in mind that it's extremely recommended that you post why you're voting for a certain entry.







Signature of the Week #50 Voting

Theme: Illustrator


Rules and Guidelines for Voting:



1) You do not have to post why you're voting for a certain entry, but it's strongly encouraged. You are NOT allowed to campaign for any specific entry, nor should you post negative comments on any other entry that you are not voting for. You should vote based upon solely what YOU like, NOT what other people are voting for.

2) NOT FOLLOWING RULE 1 WILL RESULT IN YOUR VOTE BEING DELETED.

3) This contest is designed so entries are to remain anonymous. Any reference to missing deadlines, who entered or did not enter will result in your entry being disqualified, and your post removed. You also risk being removed from further competitions of this nature.

Voting Ends Saturday, July 30th, 2011.









Entry A:




Entry B:

[Zenister]

I voted for B. I liked the style more, and it had better depth.

i like how one entry was cool colors and the other was warm, ha ha.

[th_afuro_samurai8]

I love how entry A reminds me of my favorite anime....B reminds me of my favorite band..

[Xeyuzio]

Will my vote still count if I don't vote in the poll, because I refuse to do so. Anyways I "vote" for entry A because it looks like a took a while to make and the vector was well done, entry B was also great thought but it seemed a tad simple. =P

[Nesh]

I vote for entry A, because I like the background and it's colors.

[Aleyna]

B Gets my vote, I like the musical notes. ^_^

[blueangel06661]

At first I wasn't going to vote because of the poll. It just makes things too easy as no one goes in depth as to WHY they voted for an entry. But here we go. I vote for B

Entry A: There is no flow to this signature. It's just a bunch of squares behind a render. Some large text and some smaller text. The animegalleries text does not blend with the text above it and sicks out like a sore thumb.

Entry B: This one has an elegant but sandy/beachy sort of flow. It reminds me of a music fest held at a beach. The vectors are nice and flow well. There is more pop than Entry A with a clear background middle ground and foreground.

------------

Seriously? No better reason to vote for a signature other than "oh.. I like the bg and it's colors.." "oh! I like the musical notes ^___^" /facepalm

[Meenah]

Entry B gets my vote, the only thing I don't like is the silhouette because it looks all bulky along with the kind of type that is being used on the signature. I wish it would be a little visible, however the great thing with it is that the person used it in some kind of an art-like formation (if that makes any sense at all, lol). What made me really vote for is is the use of the pen tool and the overall creativity of it.

[Bulf]

Entry A!
Abstract/geometric background ftw. I like the text too.

[Archaic Devices]

At first I wasn't going to vote because of the poll. It just makes things too easy as no one goes in depth as to WHY they voted for an entry. But here we go. I vote for B

Entry A: There is no flow to this signature. It's just a bunch of squares behind a render. Some large text and some smaller text. The animegalleries text does not blend with the text above it and sicks out like a sore thumb.

Entry B: This one has an elegant but sandy/beachy sort of flow. It reminds me of a music fest held at a beach. The vectors are nice and flow well. There is more pop than Entry A with a clear background middle ground and foreground.

------------

Seriously? No better reason to vote for a signature other than "oh.. I like the bg and it's colors.." "oh! I like the musical notes ^___^" /facepalm

If you want, you don't have to vote in the poll, but in a post like Xey did. Just be sure to state that you did not vote in the poll.


Anyway, this was a tough one for me because I have no idea what Illustrator is like. So I'll just have to go based on how the sigs look.

Entry A: Interesting choice. The background colors compliment the character, and it has this cool abstract feel to it. But I'm no so sure the abstract feel works well with the character. There's really no blending, and I'm very torn on the text. The font works well with the feel of the sig, but it's so big and also doesn't blend very well.
Entry B: This is almost the exact opposite of A. It uses bright colors, and tries to show some depth with overlapping lines. I like the silhouette effect and the bright colors, but the sun rays effect seems overdone. You also can't see the entire text of AG.net.

Overall I go with B. It shows depth and has better use of colors.

[Nanobyte]

Voted for entry B because I like the simple yet ingenious design, and it gives me a warm and sunny feeling, just like the summer. ^-^
I couldn't find animegalleries at first, but I found it! =D