The title, is what my band director has been chorusing at us for the past two years. After Dumbledore died, we had a huge disscusion during advisory on it. Our band director entered it saying that he isn't dead.
Here are his theories:
1.) Snape and Dumbledore are half brothers and had it all planned out
2.) When falling off the tower, it was not really Dumbledore.
3.) A death eater or a-something took Dumbledore's place.
Here is what we retorted.
1.) In no way are they half brothers, Dumbledore is way older then Snape, maybe by hundreds of years, and he never fully trusted snape.
2-3.) The phoneix leaves the school which would only happen if Dumbledore was dead. And the second part of this is Dumbledore's picture was on the wall with the other departed headmasters..
Does anyone have theroies for it or not? Cause I'm not signalling out the possibility have him not being dead, but I just think he is.
Yeah so let the Dumbledore rampage, begin.