Gundam V.S Evangelion....Any Comments?

[Spectre]

I think Gundam would win.....

[Crimson Phoenix]

Which Gundam series? Gundam Wing, Gundam SEED, Gundam SEED Destiny, Mobile Suit Gundam 0079/0080/0083, Gundam X, Gundam Z, Gundam ZZ? Which series? if you leave it open to any of them, I'd have to say that the Wing Zero from Gundam Wing would win against any Eva you want to set up for the chopping block.

[dragongundam009]

That's if it could get pass it's apt .

[shadow_alchemist92]

i think against Most gundams, evangelion would win

[BlackRose Vampiress]

i think against Most gundams, evangelion would win

I totally agree...

[hunt4me]

naw, I'd go for Gundam all the way. It's soooooooo much better!!! and the characters are sooo much more...amazing looking!!!! hahahahahahaaaaa!!!! I love Gundam Wing!!! Gundam has my vote!

[Manhattan_Project_2000]

Evangelions. I don't even think it'd be fair. Even throwing out Berserker Mode, the AT Fields, Regeneration, and the Prog Knives, Evas are still 260 ft to a Gundam's 60ish.

Let's put it this way. Eva's can win against Angels, but there is no way I'd believe a Gundam could beat some of the Angels, like for example Ramiel, Iruel, Leliel, or Zeruel.
A Gundam against any of those would stand no chance what-so-ever.

[raziel]

Gundam all the way. eva better stick angels

[bakakame]

I'm confident that any gundam would get soundly thrashed by an EVA. Just look at what an EVA is, I don't think there needs to be much more explination than that.

[Aminity]

I don't know which ones would win, but I prefer Evangelion myself.

[Maya Miyazono]

Series or the mecha's in general?

Either way...Eva is more advanced.

[samuriagent]

eva's could beat down on a gundam, but gundams are just....well, cooler

[AzNTediZ]

Gundam all the way

[Manhattan_Project_2000]

You know, I figured it out, and to put it in simple terms, if the Eva were 6ft tall, the Gundam would be about 1.5 ft tall. Both are roughly humanoid, the Gundam’s admittedly are a bit more mobile, however, I think the scale factor is just too much for this fight to be fair, or even in most cases, close.

[Flaming Comet]

Evangelions Would Squish Gundams Like Bugs, Besides The Only Reason The Gundam Name Is So Popular Is That It Has Like OneHundred Differnt Versions Of It, Evangelion Has Held Its Own With Just 26 Episodes And Two Movies.......So There

[AzNTediZ]

Gundam Rulez...i wish gundams were real but considering the consequences and that our technology is nothing compared to gundam's. My favorite gundams are Deathscythe Hell Cutom and Epyon. I love Gundam wing and SEED but i missed G gundam and the first. I loved the movie Endless Waltz. I hope they continue on to the series and add more gundams. The games are worth playing if u r a fan. but i myself think there should be more control avalaible.

[Masali]

Gundam Rulez...i wish gundams were real but considering the consequences and that our technology is nothing compared to gundam's. My favorite gundams are Deathscythe Hell Cutom and Epyon. I love Gundam wing and SEED but i missed G gundam and the first. I loved the movie Endless Waltz. I hope they continue on to the series and add more gundams. The games are worth playing if u r a fan. but i myself think there should be more control avalaible.

For those of you who follow the idiot's path, such as this fine example shown above I'll put it into simple terms.



VS.




that's an accurate comparison on size and ferocity.

[the anime freak]

i would definatly want the gundams to win but lets take a look at the facts here the eva is much larger than a normal gundam unit and eva has such advanced fighting capabiliteis that they have at fields regenaration if you count the eva series flight if you count the eva series also such as a gundams most advanced fighting weapon is nothing more than a toy for the evas such as a beam rifle or a saber maybe a beam chain or cannon so even tho i would like for the gundams to win the odds are against them so i would have to say the eva simply because it is far more advanced

[Prons]

Oh god.

First and foremost it's worth noting that Gundam and Evangelion are two different types of robot shows. Gundam is an old school military show, Evangelion is a new school watered down hype show.

Second of all, the Evangelions rely 100% on their AT fields, they aren't very strong without them and have the umbilical cord disadvantage. For example, in Super Robot Wars, if an enemy can pierce their AT Field, they get blown away, but because most enemies can't, they can pretty much take down most enemy robots.

Third, it's worth noting that Gundams are more mobile than the Evangelions, in particular the SEED "flying around at mind blowing speeds shooting a million lasers in every direction" robots.

Of course, that's if they were to fight.

However, In terms of show quality, Gundam is infinetly better. Of course, this is lost on the fact that most people here have only seen Wing, SEED or maybe 8th.

[the anime freak]

i dissagree look at the facts the evas would utterly crush the gundams

[Char The Red Comet]

Oh god.

First and foremost it's worth noting that Gundam and Evangelion are two different types of robot shows. Gundam is an old school military show, Evangelion is a new school watered down hype show.

Second of all, the Evangelions rely 100% on their AT fields, they aren't very strong without them and have the umbilical cord disadvantage. For example, in Super Robot Wars, if an enemy can pierce their AT Field, they get blown away, but because most enemies can't, they can pretty much take down most enemy robots.

Third, it's worth noting that Gundams are more mobile than the Evangelions, in particular the SEED "flying around at mind blowing speeds shooting a million lasers in every direction" robots.

Of course, that's if they were to fight.

However, In terms of show quality, Gundam is infinetly better. Of course, this is lost on the fact that most people here have only seen Wing, SEED or maybe 8th.

Yes so true I agree with you on the shows

As for the VS what about Turn A and Turn X.
And woodent the Gundam Double X's twin satellite cannon pierce the EVA's AT Field?

[Starkwynd]

Simply put, no. Gundams all around don't have the power to pierce an AT field.

I posted some data before, but it's been way too long I'm not looking for that post, if you want i can manually post it again but let me just give you the general idea, Gundam's don't stand a chance.

As for the second paragraph on Prons post, that is completely wrong. Behind the AT field (which a gundam can't get past anyway) is 16000 plates of fortified armor that, based on anecdotal evidence in the show, makes gundanium and phase shift look like cheap recycled paper. Underneith the 16000 plates of armor is a being of immense power (which is actually being RESTRAINED by the armor) that is capeable of regenerating itself if damaged. Going another step foreward, Unit 1 has an S2 engine, which means no umbilicle cord to cut since it has an infinate power supply right there.

With the exception of a few, Gundams are conventional weapons, designed to fight OTHER conventional weapons, not a super-being (EVA).

[Red Phantoms]

Where the fight going on? In colony, earth or space? In the space battle and colony battle Im sure that gundam will. But in the earth the big guy like GPO3 Dendrobium will become easy prey for smaller and more agille Evanglion. or maybe the Gundam Mk 2 wich spealize in space battle cannot match Evanglion close range attack so I vote for Evanglion

[NecroGate]

Gundam for me

[Prons]

i dissagree look at the facts the evas would utterly crush the gundams

Okay, let us look at the facts.

Evas can't fly, save for the MP evas. This is an advantage when you consider that the Gundams in pretty much every universe are pretty dang mobile, they really do get around.

Meanwhile, Evangelions are pretty much close combat, save for a few weapons, the Lance of Longinus (Spelling) which is disadvantaged by the fact that it's too slow. If anything, the machine guns would have a chance to hit them.

But then we have a technology gap where a majority of Gundams, save for a few early examples like the Zaku II, they all pretty much use lasers. Well, it's a known fact lasers = fast. Meanwhile, the Evangelions use machine guns because Eva is a more "Modern Day" show than Gundam, which is a more "Future-Age" show.

So the Evas don't have too much going in the way of offenser, when you consider that the Gundam's could fly around in the sky all day and wait for
the Evas to run out of ammo, then they'd be down to the progressive knives.


However, the Evangelions have A.T fields, so they have a pretty solid defense, unless the Gundam can crack it. But it's worth noting that the A.T. Field like all plot devices can be as strong or as weak as the scene needs be. If the story demmands it, it can be pierced by the Lance of Longinus, mind you.

And with that said, you can't win a fight with just defense.

While we're on the subject, it's worth noting that Evangelions need umbilical cords, quite frankly if a Gundam were to snap it\the power source, the Eva would be screwed.

S
As for the second paragraph on Prons post, that is completely wrong. Behind the AT field (which a gundam can't get past anyway) is 16000 plates of fortified armor that, based on anecdotal evidence in the show, makes gundanium and phase shift look like cheap recycled paper. Underneith the 16000 plates of armor is a being of immense power (which is actually being RESTRAINED by the armor) that is capeable of regenerating itself if damaged. Going another step foreward, Unit 1 has an S2 engine, which means no umbilicle cord to cut since it has an infinate power supply right there.

Ah! Here's where the plot device I mentioned starts happening.

In the End of Evangelion when the head of Asuka's unit gets pirced with the L.o.L, infact, we see Eva armor get screwed up a lot in the show.

So if they were to fight, at the very end there is one result: Space Runaway Ideon flying in ontop the Battleship Yamato with the universe's biggest beer keg.