Question: If a Tree falls in the middle of a forest..And no one's ( Know one's.. etc..) around to hear it.. does it make a sound? o_O;
|AnimeGalleries [dot] Net||AnimeWallpapers [dot] Com||AnimeLyrics [dot] Com||AnimePedia [dot] Com||AnimeGlobe [dot] Com|
That depends on if anyone's there to hear it.
A.K.A. Torturous Anodyne / Nocturne Filth / ~Devilish Kidnapper~ / KuromaruA Fan?
Yes i think it does
I guess it would make a sound.
-FMA18-New signature soon, hopefully. =3
HELL YEAH IT MAKES A SOUND! It just depends if you're there to hear it or not.
it depends on where you are.if u are near the forest or live in it,you would hear the sound unless ur listening to music o.O
Sometimes The Minute You Give Up On Everything Somebody Shows Up And Cheers You Up Right Before Your Very Eyes It Happened To Me And He Knows Who He Is I Hope.
Well...what precisely do you mean? So let's see, sound are the vibrations transmitted through an elastic solid or a liquid or gas, with frequencies in the approximate range of 20 to 20,000 hertz, capable of being detected by human organs of hearing. The gas sound vibrates is air, and there's nothing in space, so that's why there's no sound in space. <_<
But ah, if there's not a human there to hear it, it doesn't qualify as sound. But still, without a person there to hear, the air STILL vibrates, making a sound. So screw the definiton, yes, it makes a sound.
Or do you mean, does a tree fall in a forest on a planet with no atmosphere? But that'd be impossible, because there can be no sentient life without an atmosphere. :P What a simple question.
I think it would make a sound, but of course, no one would be around to hear it. If you put a camera or something there, then someone would technically be around to hear it. It's really impossible to test, I suppose.
I don't know...
-Back! From Outer Space!--Soldats Royal Family-
I learned that it is only considered "sound" if the wave/ vibrations bouncing off of other objects reach the ear. So, no I guess it wouldn't be considered a sound. I actually wanted to know the answer, so I picked up an encyclopedia like 5 years ago. Although, there's really not a forest that is totally empty. There's always some type of animal living in a forest.
"A woman is like a tea bag, you cannot tell how strong she is until you put her in hot water."
- Nancy Reagan
maybe that tree doesnt want anybody around to see it scream in agony when it crashes to the ground. so that leads to the conclusion to go invisible so the tree wont see you and watch, observe, take notes, etc....
AMEN to that lol i was thinknig the same thing hahaOriginally Posted by Sakura Shinguuji
o god im not very good with these things but i sappose it does yes so whta if no one around to hear it why dont you get a tree with nothing else there and put a tape to it and find out ?? always thinking locgical haha
lol an illusion haha who has an illusion tree plus you would need the box to tip side whys to fall if you know what i meen and it would take someone to do that haha
Okay... so you don't want that thread to become a think-fest but still are you asking a question demanding "thoughts". For what? In order to bring forth a couple of insipid pre-chewed answers, not too bright but seeming clever to then tell yourself: fantastic, I'm an intellectual? Marvelous.
Well, well. Not to repeat what Ch33zyph33r said I'll further. The very conception of tree, sound, atmosphere and "philosophical questions" is tributary ot the existence of one who thinks it. So, without the thinker to imagine the sound, the question or the situation, nothing. It's as plain as that.
-I have an hangover and two liters of coffee in the body: I'm at the top of my efficiency.-
If I love trains it is probably because they go faster than burials.
The best thing about weasels is that they don't turn into pickles when they are you.
Yes, even thought no-one is there to hear it
Have a bomb set off on the bottom of a tree and put a recorder aroud that area... leave so you won't hear anything then return when the bomb sets off and the tree falls and get the recorder... Listen tot eh recorder and see if it makes sound...
I think it will... ^_^
a tree should make noise if it falls if not well then next on Unsolved mysteries:
what if a tree falls and no one is around to hear it?
what if a bomb goes off and no one is alive to hear it does it make a sound?
what if a deaf man farts and no one is around to hear does it make a sound?...
the fart one therd defenatly be a smell
of corus it makes a sound it's like asking if a piano fell on your foot does it hurt?
lol damn i was gonna say of course it does why are we even discussing this plus dandy chan im sorry im not to bright not all can be as intelligent as you. and plus i was joking about what i said maybe your not as smart as you look if you carnt even tell when im joking
yes it makes a sound even though no one is around to hear it its a riddle that i can answer millions of times and ill get it right. Sakura hears a riddle for u "Whats the sound of one hand claping?"
When darkness falls light fades when there is darkness it's hard to see everyone and everything is lost in the darkness things fade and sometimes don't come back chaos will over come some because light no longer luminates the path but when light returns darkness fades now light rules for a while but darkness comes back to drown out light once again
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)