In your experience, has there been a game you've played that has received so much praise and critical acclaim and been labeled by some as "the greatest game ever made", but when you actually play it your thoughts include "Is that all it is?!"
If so, post that game here!
As for myself, I know I'm going to be really hated by many of you. But this is an opinion thread so, here goes nothing.
Halo. To me, there was nothing in it that I haven't seen in other FPS's (with the sole exception of the vehicles). I give it an 8 / 10 at best.