I was reading Yahoo Shine when I saw this:
And it made me think, what should I do if that were the case?
I'm undecided. It depends.
Anyway, one thing is for sure. If that jewelry is something of an heirloom, I'd certainly give it back.
Do you have any similar experiences regarding this, be it jewelry or other things? For the guys, would you want us to return it?
Also, what if the parting wasn't good? Like he was cheating on you, something like that. Would you still feel obliged to return an engagement ring or would you rather throw it or sell it as part of your revenge?