Printable View
I started a thread about the anime Prism Ark just a few days ago. It's now gone. It's not locked. It broke no rules. I've received no infraction, nor or any PM warning me about any content in that thread from any administrator or moderator. The thread is just GONE! If there it was deleted by accident, please find a way to retrieve it.
The first video you linked contained a scene of nudity, secondly you explicitly stated in the first post - which I somehow overlooked - that there were scenes of nudity in the video-game, and even worse in the anime.
This is a PG-13 site, and I do not want young members searching for new anime to watch to inadvertently end up watching a hentai/fighting series.
Furthermore, pretty much everything you posted was about the video game adaptation, not the anime ... so the majority of the discussion would have belonged in the Video Games forum, but given what I'd already assumed I decided against it. I intended to send you a message this morning about it, but you've obviously saved me the trouble.
TL;DR, I moved your thread because it's got porn in it ... and given your track record, I am not really too surprised that a) this happened and b) you started publicly whining about it. I thought you were going to behave? You have not yet posted one worthwhile thing that isn't involving hentai or politics.
Do me a favour next time - if I remove one of your posts or threads, talk to me DIRECTLY and don't call for a waaahmbulance out in public.
Thank you.
You got 3 things wrong:Quote:
Originally Posted by Ranshiin
[1] The nudity you spoke of in the video was VERY MILD. It was comparable to what is shown in Sailor Moon transformation scenes. If a Sailor Moon transformation scene video was posted here on AF, I doubt it would be removed (in fact if I took the time to look, I'd probably find there's one already posted in the Magical Girl section of these forums). Sailor Moon is generally regarded as being kid-friendly (at least as far as anime goes).
[2] I didn't post anything with porn in it. I got banned for posting hentai last time around. I'm not about to make that mistake again.
[3] I said that the game was worse than the anime. Your claim that I said that the anime was worse than the game, is mistaken.
And now a question for you. What do you mean by "This is a PG-13 site, and I do not want young members searching for new anime to watch to inadvertently end up watching a hentai/fighting series."
I'm particularly curious what you have against "fighting series". Almost every anime has battle scenes, especially popular ones like Gundam and DBZ. If you eliminate anime with fighting that probably eliminates all anime that's worth watching, and as a result would probably mean you'd have to delete all posts on AF that related to anime (which would defeat the entire purpose of this site being an anime forum).
With your very strict rules, I'm surprised that you haven't yet required me to delete my avatar and profile pics. While completely kid friendly in and of themselves, they are from screencaps of that anime called Prism Ark. If you are so afraid of kids becoming interested in a "bad anime" and then trying to look it up on the internet, to the point you wish to remove all references to that anime, then why haven't you required I change my avatar and profile pic yet?
Furthermore, the anime while R rated, was NOT really any worse than Neon Genesis Evangelion (an anime that I'm pretty sure has been mentioned here on AF at least once, and probably has a thread of its own). The level of nudity shown in the Prism Ark anime, could be approximated with that shown in various episodes of Neon Genesis Evangelion. Remember that scene in Evangelion where Shinji accidentally falls on top of Rei while she's naked? I'm guessing most people would consider that scene to be not very kid friendly, so by your logic, the ENTIRE ANIME of Neon Genesis Evangelion should NEVER be mentioned on AF, or else little kids might look it up and see the "bad scenes" in it.
It seems in other words, that you are being biased in how you handle threads, throwing threads that I make because of certain bad content (or potential to inspire others to look it up, resulting in them finding bad content), yet you DON'T throw similar threads made by OTHER people. In other words, I think you target my threads, not so much because of content, but rather because I am the one who posted it, and you have some PERSONAL GRUDGE against me.
I've given you my reasons for removing the thread. Nudity is nudity, and inappropriate pages on a website are inappropriate pages on a website.
Next time you have an issue with my judgement, take it up DIRECTLY with me instead of drama-whoring about it here and in my forum. You are not helping your own cause by having a lack of maturity about this.
edit
If your feels really mean that much, I am going to directly discuss the matter with more senior members unless they read and respond here first.
OK, I've spoken to Ranshiin and had a look at the thread.
First of all, what you've said about videos is all correct, the nudity can be compared to Sailor Moon, but not the facial expressions. Some expressions clearly imply a sexual type of nudity and that IS against the rules.
Secondly, the OP is half to re-write. Most of it is about explicit scenes, comparison between the extends of explicit scenes in the game and anime, what do you see on explicit scenes and so on. Why was such a problem to write, that the game is adult material and leave it at that?
And at last but not least, you posted character bioses straight on a website that's full of explicit material. You did warn about it, but that's not enough to stop a kid who likes the cut scenes and the description to check other pages. Not to mention that it's in Japanese, so they can't know what is what, making them click randomly on links until they find what they are looking for, which is more pictures usually.
And to end my post, I just want to mention that the thread speaks more about the game than the anime (as Ranshiin already pointed out), meaning that the thread is in the wrong area (as Ranshiin already pointed out) seeing that you wanted to focus the thread on it.
So to end this I offer you two options, the thread either stays deleted or we edit out everything that shouldn't be there, and bring it back. Which one would you prefer?
@FlashD
Quote:
Originally Posted by FlashD
Can you PM me the code for that opening post for that thread? I'll see what I can do to fix it to bring it into the forum's guidelines. I'll PM you back the edited version, to see if it meets the requirements of the forum's rules.
Also when you PM me the code for that opening post, would you please elaborate, as to which video or videos contained the content that violated forum rules, approximately what time said content was shown in the video(s), and also exactly what you found objectionable about each offending scene. This will allow me to better understand for future postings, what is and is not allowed in material posted on AF.
I don't know why you even bothered with an option @FlashD -_-
This dude can't tell the difference between appropriate and not appropriate
Sometimes the difference between appropriate and not appropriate can be a VERY fine line.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rainbow Crash
Not really. Our mods are very serious about keeping this site clean for the sake of our young members. There's no need to corrupt them!
Do not whine about things like this at all. It happened to me once, but I won't complain, even if mine was an accident.
A VG thread being discussed on?
I'm probably in the wrong forum.
Thats AF for you. These threads really never get old.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kaitou+