-
Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Signature:
In its entirety (including text, links, et cetera), rate the previous poster's signature on a scale of one to ten. So the first person to comment should rate my signature, then the second to rate that person's and so on. When rating a signature please include reasons as to why you gave that rating (things that may deduct points from a score may be image size(s), poor typography, or signature picture quality).
Avatar:
On a scale of one to ten, rate the previous poster's avatar picture on a scale of one to ten. Please support your vote with reasons as to why you voted in a particular way (you may give a ten for an avatar with your favorite character in it or a one to an avatar with absolutely no creativity). So the first person to comment should rate my avatar and the second to comment should rate that person's and so on.
Enjoy!
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
I'll give you an 8/10 because his face is cutting off and it looks a bit awkward, the avatar gets a 7/10 because it just looks like a cropped picture. o_O;;
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Right back 'atcha my friend.
Avatar: 8/10 for good lighting, but lack of C4D quality (or whatever's covering the creature's leg), and I simply don't like the render.
Signature: 7.5/10
The creature signature is win, but the Joker signature (see your thread's description for complete analysis) doesn't make the cut, and the purple font on your titles doesn't work (e.g. husband). Really it's the repetitive nature of the two signatures as well, both using yellows as a base for their templates.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Wait, SomeOtherCookies was who I rated, her post got deleted or something, >_> anyways your avatar gets a 9 because it's very nice and well organized, the signature gets a 7 because of that giant red spot. o_O;;
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Ohaithur
Avatar: 9/10
It's really simple and it matches your sig well. The text is really really hard to notice though.
Signature: Ehh...about an 8. The Bomberman one gets about a 9.5 or 10, but the Gaara one needs a little work. And your purple letters are ridiculously hard to see too lol.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Well a new set for me so a new post!
Well I know you didn't make the avatar so I won't rate it and the only I can rate is your Muse one so let's get started.
I give it a 8/10 because the left side has a lot of circles and the line on the left the one that goes across his hair would be better of behind him but overall a great signature that I would like to create one similar to that one in the future!
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
8/10
Maybe keep it at only 1 sig. (:
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
New set so time to post, I love your set. It's so imaginative and it reminds me of when I was child, I just really love looking at it. You get a 9/10, great job.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
7/10 for a great set and organized signature. With that being said, even an organized clash of elements is still a clash of elements. Keep the first signature and trash the second for an easy 8.5/10.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
I'll give this a try.
Sig: 8/10- I like how you added depth even with a small background. I love your quote too.
Avatar: 9/10- I love how it matches your sig without even trying.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Sig: 9/10 - It's not everyday when I see something like that. It reminds me of a dreamland with alot of bubbles flying around and that you can see your own reflection.
avy: 7/10 - Not very much is going on, I like the art, the color, and the depth and it can leave alot of imagination for guys/girls if they choose to look at it long enough... ^^"
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Signature - 8/10 Pretty much both are the same, just changed the renders and tone of color. But either way, they are both nicely made.
Avatar - 7/10 Not liking the boarder so much.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Signature: 7/10 - Not sure if it's the brightness mixed with the colors but it's just not appealing to me, still a solid sig though.
Avatar: 7/10 - fairly average avatar but still fits the set.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Avatar: 7/10 - Kinda plain but nice nevertheless.
Signature: N/A - The signature is broken so no rating here.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Avatar: 7/10 Nice but I'm not such a big fan of skulls.
Signature: 7/10 The first one is nice but the second is kind of empty, though I do love cars. >_<
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
8/10 - I like the concept and over all it just looks nice.
7.5/10 - The sig itself looks a little flat, but the picture is nice and a sweet concept.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Signature and avatar 10/10
cool set set and nicely done :3
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
8.5/10
If you have it only as a set, it would be so much better.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Avatar: 8/10, it's interesting, although a little busy. The colors are great, and overall, well done.
Signature: 7/10 It almost looks as if you've simply cropped a picture. If I'm wrong, this deserves a MUCH higher rating.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
avatar: 8/10 nice pic but the designs on the left side compete with her
sig: 9/10: nice pic and the color goes nicely with it
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
[doing the witch sig]
Signature: 8/10
Great composition, love the color choice and minimalism. Not very fond of the line over your username or how the style differs from the right [lots of very clean, straight lines] to the left [mostly jagged lines].
Avatar: 7/10
Its a little plain and seems like it could be a copy-paste of the sig. It keeps it very uniform with the sig, but I think it couldve been tweaked a bit so that it can stand on its own. It still a great composition, nice use of colors and lines.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Avatar- 9/10, Nicely done. :3
Signature- 10/10, Awesome effects, especially the headphones.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Avatar - 8/10 The colours amuse me =)
Signature - 9/10 The image goes well with the background and brushes
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Avatar: 9/10 - Its funny, its animated, what more can I say?
Sig: 8/10 - Very good, I like the look and feel to it. The color is done right and it reminds me of an old photo.
-
Re: Rate the Signature and Avatar above you!
Avatar: 8/10 - It's very simple
Signature: 9/10 - The effects are just great but the background doesn't blend in very well