-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Scruffy
Well folks, thanks to your votes, we will be lynching mafia today. I can guarantee you this.
Yes, I may be stubborn, but I'm also right. If you'd been following the game, you'd know that I've asked for several peoples' opinions and heard them out. So, nope, not single-minded.
How do you expect anyone to prove something in this game? Do you expect them to copy-paste their role and get themselves modkilled? Screencap investigation results? The only way things can be proven are through lynches, vigilante kills, and day/night actions.
You can't, but on the the other you're way to confident this early in the game. And if what Maru said is true about Ribbon in past games then you're simply going after a week player. Though I have to say, right now you seem like one as well. Especially claiming you ha it doesn't lend itself to be a hint at being some type of oracle and as such, you're just grasping at what ever straws you can. Hence the early vote changes.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
I'm going to sleep, guys. Hope I get back in time for the lynch post~.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
what's the lynch time in real time again, i hate having to keep looking up how bad the clocks are wrong in the States......
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Scruffy
---------- Post added at 01:20 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:15 PM ----------
[/COLOR]I am out for a few hours folks. Hopefully I'll be back in time for the lynching.
Heading out when the heat starts to go on you a bit?
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Isn't it 4 hours left?
In 4 hours, the game has been going on for a day for me.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kaitou-2
So none of us can say that word as a precaution, or does the target person know they cant?
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
-GAZKUL-
what's the lynch time in real time again, i hate having to keep looking up how bad the clocks are wrong in the States......
Like I already told SuXrys, the beginning and end of a phase is always 11 pm GMT (London time).
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ribbon
Well I reacted based on the way you responded to my question. It's obvious that you two have some sort of mutual trust. Who says you two aren't part of the Duo Mafia?
Wouldn't it make sense to have mutual respect among experienced players? I don't believe it's trust they're conveying. And just because they seem to have positive interaction with each other doesn't mean they're in any sort of faction together. Not to mention they're actually disagreeing on your case, so I don't see how you're coming up with this in the first place. Is it wrong to respect others? I personally respect everyone in this game, whether they be mafia or town. It's simply good sportsmanship. Discouraging that and suggesting that we all point fingers and scream "SCUM" at everyone without having a shred of respect makes YOU look like the arrogant one, not Scruffy.
And even if they WERE both in the mafia, you think they would make their roles that obvious?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Scruffy
No. Not everyone. But how much more clear do you want me to be?
Lynch Ribbon. If my scumdar has failed me, you all can proceed to lynch me, kill me, or do whatever you like.
Being absolutely sure on your vote is pretty admirable, but one can't help but think why. Everyone else voting Ribbon just seems to be following your lead, with little reasoning of their own. Do you encourage others blindingly following your lead? The game is about people having their own stances and gather their own evidence. They can analyze the evidence of others, of course, but calling everyone "derpy" simply because they vote differently than you in no way encourages others to play their own way. To each his own.
If I may say so, it actually makes you look a bit scummy. You're dead-set on Ribbon, as if she's the only one who could possibly be mafia at this point, when there are others as well you could be pressing. Perhaps if Ribbon is mafia, you'll earn a great deal of townie cred, which could ensure your survival even if you are mafia as well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ribbon
Of course I admit my defense is weak.
Before this post you made it sound as if you were making your absolute best defense by
1. being willing to let the Cop investigate you
2. encouraging the others to post so as to help further the town
3. asking for reasons why others are suspicious of you, when they have done so multiple times
If evidence is brought forth, then that's that. You can state a defense all you want, but now you're saying your defense was weak. Why? Why don't you try harder, if you're truly willing to help the town succeed?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ribbon
@
RyuTama - I was merely saying this because I wanted to prove myself for town. Yes I'm aware that it isn't completely right, but at least town would one one person they could trust, right?
You can provide a defense for yourself. Don't ask the Cop to go out of his or her way to investigate you. As far as I know, Cops are only allowed to send 2 PMs to the people they have investigated. That would mean there would be little the two of you could accomplish anyway, even if you were innocent. @Kaitou+ can we get a confirmation on this, or do you plan on leaving that bit of info under wraps for now?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
GameGeeks
Who said it was random? What I don't get is how he can be so sure of himself on day one. There's nothing to go on. He basses it on something called scumdar. So either he has some ability or pulling something out of his rear. Either way, he's too sure of himself on day one.
As I'm sure @The Butcher already clarified, he's always like this on DP1.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Sr Machinehead
Hmm, I can't see much right now but then again i'm speed reading I'm gonna have to go ahead and [Vote No Lynch] I'll be ready for the next day phase though or if i decide that some new post seems suspicious.
There has been plenty of discussion. And even if you are speed reading, you can scan through posts that have bolded votes and legitimate reasonings to base your input off of. Saying you'll "get back to us later" and then voting No Lynch without even a shred of actual contribution makes you look like you're 1. giving the mafia a free day phase, and 2. trying to avoid suspicion by blindly following a bandwagon or random voting. Either way, it doesn't make you look too innocent.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
MikuChuu
@
Daken I don't see why it matters, I mean it happened hours ago why is this still being brought up. I don't see any significance that it would have.
Evidence is significant at any point in the game.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Screwby
Kaitou never lies.
...I lol'd.
-cough- Anyway, even if you are a townie, you can still provide a defense for yourself. Just as much as I don't really fall for role-hinting/claiming, it could be a new role that Kaitou has introduced that makes someone look innocent, even if they were the Godfather or other scum. I seriously wouldn't put it past him to implement that kind of ability into the game. Not to mention there was a game where a Seer always got an "innocent" result, which is pretty similar to the aforementioned ability. For now, I see you as noteworthy of being scum as anyone else.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ZombieWolf2508
@
RyuTama I bring up that last game because less-experienced wolves will act in a similar way.
Then let them learn on their own. If you're a townie there's no need for giving wolves tips. How do you know there are inexperienced wolves playing anyway? Wow. Major slip if you ask me.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
SuXrys
So, no matter if someone is townie or a wolf, you want them to stay in the game just because they are active? Sounds... a little weird.
Killing off the active players right at the start makes discussion among townies nearly impossible, seeing as how people tend to keep quiet unless brought out into the spotlight.
I'm sorry for not jumping on the Ribbon bandwagon with you Scruffy, but I'll have to [Vote Lynch ZombieWolf2508], for the reasoning I stated in the red text above.
---------- Post added at 11:03 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:02 AM ----------
Derp, I'm off again for right now guys. I've given my input for the moment. I hope to be back in an hour or two.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
SuXrys
Don't forget about Screwby that say he didn't agree with all the voting against Ribbon, because Ribbon and Scruffy are the most active players do he didn't want them to go away. Could be that Screw is a wolf, and in the same team as Ribbon and thus don't want Ribbon to be voted of. But writes in Scruffy in the meaning aswell so it won't look so suspicious.
Oh yes, neither have I forgotten the fact that he has yet to vote.
Some Wolves may wait till the last minute to vote just so that there's enough room for them to try to reverse an unfavorable situation. *coughcough* what are you still waiting for, my dear?
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
I just realized I screwed up. >_>
Re-read the AG ability in few mins.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
animeyay
Like I already told SuXrys, the beginning and end of a phase is always 11 pm GMT (London time).
Yayz!!!! i'll actually be awake for this one!!!!
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
I made a kind of made an error. @_@
No one is restricted to say the word "town". However it it was the case, only the target player is affected.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
oh wow, I just realized there's @Kaitou+ and @Kaitou-2 ...
Talk about split personality ._.
http://i1191.photobucket.com/albums/...s/TRfrozen.jpg
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
animeyay
I'm using it to avoid my posts being merged. I don't like that crap for Mafia games.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kaitou+
I'm using it to avoid my posts being merged. I don't like that crap for Mafia games.
lol I admire you for your dedication for the game~
and sorry for the distraction people. carry on XD
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Something has come up IRL and I will be back shorty. I need to take a break and get my mind straight. That way I don't screw up again.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
If Ribbon was a innocent townie, couldn't she request a modkill for herself to prove so? Unless you cannot do that . ___ ." Then I got nothing.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Dark Butterfly
If Ribbon was a innocent townie, couldn't she request a modkill for herself to prove so? Unless you cannot do that . ___ ." Then I got nothing.
A Townie should only attempt modkill if that action can directly prove that someone else is scum. Like in the previous game, I was modkilled, but in turn ZombieWolf was exposed to be the head mafia. Ribbon requesting a modkill now wouldn't be able to help us identify any mafia, so it would be a wasted kill.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Dark Butterfly
If Ribbon was a innocent townie, couldn't she request a modkill for herself to prove so? Unless you cannot do that . ___ ." Then I got nothing.
If she modkills, then we're down a possible townie and could vote off another one. Asking her to do so seems more like you want a townie gone....
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
animeyay
A Townie should only attempt modkill if that action can directly prove that someone else is scum. Like in the previous game, I was modkilled, but in turn ZombieWolf was exposed to be the head mafia. Ribbon requesting a modkill now wouldn't be able to help us identify any mafia, so it would be a wasted kill.
I thought it would disprove Scruffers but it is the first day phase, so you can't really hold anything against anyone quite yet.
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Dark Butterfly
I thought it would disprove Scruffers but it is the first day phase, so you can't really hold anything against anyone quite yet.
Yea, the problem is, disproving Scruffy right now probably won't get us anywhere, 'cause the target he accused would be dead anyways from the modkill lol
-
Re: Wolf XVII: Anime Forum Chronicles
:'D I didn't mean it that way Maru. ..I never thought about such, I really need to think about my motives more >_>"