Signature of the Week #65 Voting
Signature of the Week #65 Voting
Theme: Eragon
Rules and Guidelines for Voting:
1) You do NOT have to state your reason for voting, but it’s strongly recommended you do. You are NOT allowed to campaign for any specific entry, nor should you post negative comments on any other entry that you are not voting for. You should vote based upon solely what YOU like, NOT what other people are voting for.
2) NOT FOLLOWING RULE 1 WILL RESULT IN YOUR VOTE BEING DELETED.
3) This contest is designed so entries are to remain anonymous. Any reference to missing deadlines, who entered or did not enter will result in your entry being disqualified, and your post removed. You also risk being removed from further competitions of this nature.
Voting Ends Friday, November 25th 2011.
Entry A:
http://i1083.photobucket.com/albums/.../entry-a-2.png
Entry B:
http://i1083.photobucket.com/albums/.../entry-b-2.png
Entry C:
http://i1083.photobucket.com/albums/.../entry-c-2.png
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
So many upward camera angles. XD
I really like C, except for the text. None of the font faces are very fitting or well-placed, but it has nice enough effects.
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
I vote C. I actually like the composition of the text. Plus I like C's use of the C4Ds.
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
They are all so good. But I vote for A.
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
Entry A display something different than the others, it has a dragon. So that got my attention, followed by good type and the interesting steampunk like-feel to it. It's real cool.
Entry B has good depth and has a little more colour. I'm not a fan of the type and it's just too bright for me. I wish more was done but oh well. Again, great depth and colour.
Entry C I would say it's my least favourite. It's just twice as brighter than B, maybe that's just me. The scattering of C4Ds isn't appealing, too high in contrast, and most certainly I don't like the typography. Just looks a little boring, I'm real sorry it could of been better but it's just boring to me.
I personally think Entry A looked better, maybe it's because the composition in general is better and honest to say I was a little more attracted to it. So it gets my vote.
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
Voting's closed, but I'll post my opinions here for the sake of critique.
I liked Entry A. The effects on the signature blend the render into the signature just enough. The typography on Entry A also matches well with the rest of the signature. Entry B would have easily been my second choice, and the only things that set it back for me were the C4D layering and that I was just not liking the render's angle all too much. Entry C's typography does blend well, but I cannot read some of the text in it. Entry C also made the C4D layering much more obvious than Entry B.
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Skillero
Voting's closed, but I'll post my opinions here for the sake of critique.
I liked Entry A. The effects on the signature blend the render into the signature just enough. The typography on Entry A also matches well with the rest of the signature. Entry B would have easily been my second choice, and the only things that set it back for me were the C4D layering and that I was just not liking the render's angle all too much. Entry C's typography does blend well, but I cannot read some of the text in it. Entry C also made the C4D layering much more obvious than Entry B.
Feel free to make a vote anyway. Every vote counts.
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
Since the polls are closed and Ralph wanted me to vote... I vote for A. It has the easiest to read fonts and the colors work very nicely together. The background really makes no sense though... and the little light dots were unneeded, but overall I think it is the best out of the three.
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
I vote for A as it has the cleanest/easiest to read text. I also like how well the composition goes together and the color choices used. The light spots are a bit distracting on it, but still wins over the other two.
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Observer
Feel free to make a vote anyway. Every vote counts.
Then I'd go for Entry A. But didn't the voting close? I'm confused.
Re: Signature of the Week #65 Voting
Why does every vote count of the winners have already been chosen and listed? That makes no sense.