What FMA Character will win?

[Nature Alchemist]

Ed vs. Al
Scar vs. Roy
Wrath vs. Ed
Armstrong vs. Ironblood Alchemist

The first up is ED VS. AL who will win?:rolleyes:
Please vote and then post your own commits after you vote Thanks much.:laugh:

[animeadmirer]

Ed. Al would more likely to let his brother win than to hurt him further. Of course, that's assuming Al is at his normal state of mind.

[Holly Strife]

Erhm,...My opinion..Al would win. Just because he is full metal and Ed only has what..o_o; A metal arm and leg? x3 Yeah. Not to mention when they spar Al always kicks Ed's butt.

[WatermelonX]

Definitely Al, he is more badass than Ed...IMO

[Case_Closed_Freak]

I like ed as a character more but he's not full metal like the Al, Al would win

[Nature Alchemist]

Colonel Roy Mustang vs. Scar

YOu know what to do you guys vote and post!


WHO WILL WIN!?!

Round 1 winner was Al.

[Zeke_Asakura]

In my opinion,it's Eddy!

[Nature Alchemist]

Im sorry you guys I cant I dont know how to put more votes up so will still do round 1 for now.

[sirius]

I think Eddy will win again. If Roy I think he will get rank 4.

[Nature Alchemist]

Ok people we will go on just without the polls

[Nature Alchemist]

Sorry for the 2 post but next up is Scar vs. Roy begin

[m1abrams]

I think alot of people underestimate Ed...not only becuase he is short (hehe), but becuase they see him as too gentle around Al. I think if he was really trying Ed would kick Al's butt, however since they are so close to one another I dont think there will ever be a time when they will go all out against each other.

However on a side note when they work together in a fight they can kick anyones arse, like Armstrong. That was amusing.

[Shinigami Ichigo]

Mustang could wipe the floor with Scar, because he doesn't have to get anywhere near him to be effective. Scar's ability relies completely on being within arm's reach. Mustang is the man :D

[Nature Alchemist]

Ok um M1 please stay on topic please.

[Shinigami Ichigo]

How about you Nature? Who do you think would win in the second round?

[Nature Alchemist]

You would probly hate me if i say this but i am going to go with scar because if he touches anything if will explode of something.

[Shinigami Ichigo]

Good point. I just go with Mustang, because he has the whole long range thing. But I am not sure on his actual fighting skills... so if that was the determining factor, then I would probably go with Scar as well.

[Nature Alchemist]

Mmm but scar is the best.

[Shinigami Ichigo]

Maybe, if he can get in close. THat is my argument for Mustang over Scar.

[Benitora_shadowman]

For the first poll, I would say Ed can beat Al. Al always beats Ed, but Ed is stronger than Al. For the second poll. I choose Roy and not Scar. Roy has an advantage since he can do the flame alchemy in far distance, but with water being the weakness. I agree that scar needs to be at arms reach to use his powers. I dont know how Roy really fights physically, I haven't seen it. Final answer, I go for Roy!

[Shinigami Ichigo]

That's my argument as well. It would be more easy to make a decision if I had seen Mustang fight close range at all.

[Sexy Angel]

edward elric~

[Shinigami Ichigo]

But he even says that he had never been able to defeat Al even once :D

[Nature Alchemist]

Shini one question are you or was you Straw Hat Pirate? THE LAST UP IS WRATH AND ED!!!!!! GO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[snowleopard224]

Ed could totaly beat Wrath

[Shinigami Ichigo]

Wrath is the shape-shifter right? I would go with him, if for no other reason than Ed is not immortal, and as far as I know doesn't have a part of his original body (or whatever it is that counteracts homunculus). Also, this is the last one? What about Armstrong's match? And why is Ed in it twice? Just wondering :p

[Nature Alchemist]

No he is not.

[Death Warrior]

Edward if you are talking about alchemy, and Al if you are talking about fighting hand to hand.

[Nature Alchemist]

CAnt agure with you there Death.

[Gizoku]

yea but al can be distroyed like those guys, and ed well i go with him

[Chouji]

ed would win even though they would never fight

[Nature Alchemist]

One Of My Fu*cking Characters Has Died Damn Damn Damn

[Truly Alone]

Edward Elric would win beause Alphonse Elric wouldn't finish Ed off. Al is too soft.

[Blood Angel]

Edward definetly Ed rocks

[Chia_Pet]

alphonso!because he's cool xD

[Nobunaga]

I think Ed win because he doesn´t need to make a diagram to in fight, and his arm and leg are of an special iron.

[NVLM_ZK]

Edward Elric???
I think and maybe........

but, nice poll topics.
Keep do it. XD

[naiume]

ed.!

[Nature Alchemist]

Last round GO GO GO!!!!!!

[Bad Envy]

Edward!!!I don't know why...but I love him!:)

[Chaos Master Dark]

Ed vs. Al
Scar vs. Roy
Wrath vs. Ed
Armstrong vs. Ironblood Alchemist

1st round: Edward
2nd round: Scar
3rd round: Edward
4th round: Armstrong

thats who i think would win.

[mini-Mimiru7]

definately Ed

[.Lovebeat]

Well...if it was Al VS. Ed...Al would win because Ed just always lose against Al >.<

[Uchiha Ulquiorra]

I would have to say. Edward would win against Al, if it was in the anime series. If it was the movie version of the two brothers, Al would definatly win, but that's all i'm gonna say about that.. Don't want to give out any spoilers.

[dark_ice]

Alphonse

[Mr. blue-reddragoon]

Alphonse Elric

[Nature Alchemist]

X.x WOW I HAVE BEEN GONE FOR A LONG TIME CAN A MOD CLOSE THIS THREAD PLEASE

[animeangellover]

IN my opinion i think Al as well

[bug]

I think Edward would win because of his great alchemy abilitys.

[Nature Alchemist]

If people are still on here talking the NVM. XD

[Subaru Blue]

Ed vs. Al
Ed

Scar vs. Roy
Roy

Wrath vs. Ed
Ed

Armstrong vs. Ironblood Alchemist
I don't know who the Ironblood alchemist is yet

[inuyasha_lover7089]

Edward Will Defenatly Win

[Nature Alchemist]

Wow I have been gone for so long that I dont know where I left off at xd

[Mamushi]

Ed
Roy
ed
Don't know about the last....

[NarutoxHinata]

For me the result are:
Ed vs Al ----> Ed is the WINNER!!
Scar vs Roy ----> Scar is the WINNER!!
Wrath vs Ed ----> Ed is the WINNER!!
Armstrong vs Ironblooded Alchemist ----> Armstrong is the WINNER!!

[shadow_dragon_3]

ed. hes better

[shadow_dragon_3]

dude, scar blows everything up. Roy cant win

[~Pure Soul~]

I think that edd will win all the way threw.

[Coraline]

OMGoodness! My honey, Roy above all! And then Edward. He's such a cutie. =]

[Zanethose]

Ed beats Al....but i still say that Armstrong could take them all out

[dog199200]

well I picked Al would deferat Ed but it realy depends witch Al your talking about the Movie Al or the Series Al, Becouse the Movie all would kick Edwards but right out of the water but the series Al wouldn't stand a chance.